No TV Experiment

Limit Screen Time Kids TV Usage Too Much TV No Tv Home Practical Parenting Lifestyle

It’s almost unheard of in today’s society for kids to not have any exposure to television right? Sad truth! This sounds downright crazy to some people…. I can hear the jeers, “What nonsense are you talking woman??” 😂

Actually, having a no tv childhood is a good thing! Studies have shown the significant difference in behavior & academic ability in children who have little, to no TV exposure.

Post Contains Affiliate Links full disclosure can be found on my Disclaimer page.



 

I decided to conduct this experiment because my unruly 6 year old was wearing me down!! Everything was a battle. Always shouting, I’m sure the neighbours think I’m stark raving mad!

Something had to give! Upon reading an article (I stopped watching tv & this is what happened) I had an epiphany! I really enjoyed reading it & was impressed at just what can be achieved by eliminating something as tiny as TV from your life. It was a real eye opener & my husband literally watches no tv, so he has always disapproved of my daughter’s tv consumption.

Did you know children spend an average of 4-8 hours in front of a screen per day! & less than 1 hour outside? Too much screen time can cause sleep problems, higher risk for attention disorders, higher risk for obesity and change the chemistry of your child’s brain! This is a scary thought! Yes, we can get stuff done while they’re in-front of the tv, but they deserve to be doing some activities, or outside exploring, getting dirty. Not watching someone on tv doing those exact things!

So began the no “zombie” zone in my house. I decided to start with weekdays, I didn’t want to go all military mum & completely eliminate any tv from her life, because I feel it’s harsh so I chose Sun-Thurs (Sunday is the 1st day if the week in the UAE) leaving the weekend to watch a maximum of 4 hours of tv. When I was a kid, kids tv only ever came on after school for a bit, or Saturday mornings (my favourites) nowadays there’s a multitude of tv channels dedicated to non stop viewing for kids. This is a problem, kids need balance, not to be exposed to something as much as they like, for as long as they like! It’s proven that too much exposure to TV has an effect on behavior, learning & social interaction.

Nobody Said It Would Be Easy!

As with anything, the first hurdle is always the hardest! If you’re going to try this experiment, you must make a plan & stick to it!

Have a back up of resources to keep them busy & take their mind off not having the tv on! (background TV is equally as bad as it’s a distraction from everything)

Prepare for the worst – Tantrums, hissy fits, lashing out, bad words… whatever they’ve got, they’ll give it!!

Don’t give in not even in the slightest!! My mum used to say, you’ve got to be cruel, to be kind sometimes.

Establish routine kids need stability, so while they notice the “gap” in their day that the tv once used to fill, make that time specific for other things.

Week 1 –

I had already sat my daughter down & explained that her behavior isn’t the best & as a result there would be no more TV! She obviously didn’t believe me, as I always give in. Not this time!

The week began – after school, she usually comes home, out of the heat & just wants to flop on couch & watch t.v…. I like her to wash up, change out of school uniform & eat something, but this becomes a daily battle, because shes already flown into the living room & grabbed the remote – no going back now!! I used to let her cool off & have the t.v. This is ok for 30 mins or so, but when it comes to getting her to change out of uniform & doing something else, it becomes WW3! So first thing was to eliminate the initial tv watching when she got home. Remotes were hidden, tv was off, set top box was also off! I braced myself for what was to come – “mummy, where’s the remote?” I told myself – Play dumb, just play dumb!

So began the whining 🙄 not just whining, nagging, constantly asking for t.v….. “I honestly don’t know where it is!” I entertained her idea to look for it, with no luck. The 1st day was truly the beginning of a few battles, but I’m usually a fly off the handle mum (bad thing I know) but I was trying my utmost best to not shout, not to react in a big way, we were graced with hissy fits, bouts of “you’re so mean!” Crying, screaming, things being thrown – whatever she had, she gave it to us good!

As the days went on, I noticed more peace in the house, no bickering between the kids over watching & no more of me having to yell at my eldest becaude he wants to watch innapropriate teen dramas while she is around! – bliss!

Week 2 –

This week saw the beginning of change around the house! She no longer asks for t.v. when she comes home. Remotes are still hidden away, but she comes home & although she still is a little defiant, it’s much easier to get her to wash her hands & change into her pj’s.

She’s more enthusiastic to do other things, the toy room she neglected is being used again! She is doing more crafts, much more games & puzzles & she even set up a reading corner for her & her dolls!!! 😳 This is amazing, as she really dislikes reading – major improvements!!

Week 3

I wanted to see how she is when others are watching tv. So we tried a few times having the radio on in the background, this was ok, when she asked to change the tv, I simply told her tv isn’t working only radio can be played. We also tried while watching animal planet. That didn’t go down too well, we had her patting down our pockets & searching us like a police officer for the remotes, funny at the time, but I decided to go back to zero t.v. to eliminate any fuss!

Week 4

Amazing progress!! We can actually have the t.v. on, without her wanting to watch!! (Bearing in mind it’s not kids t.v.) Also, during the weekend, she actually walked away from watching t.v. to play!! This may seem normal to others, but a big improvement on her part! Her yearning for the t.v. looks to be a thing of the past, so far so good!

The behavior has changed dramatically for the better! She is less aggressive, listens more & is arguing less with her brother. She is more interactive with those around her, wants to play & is more interested in arts & craft activities (before I’d need to drag her away from the tv to join in) I really don’t know why I let things escalate as much as I did, I feel I failed as a parent allowing my child to be exposed to tv as much as she was! But we live & learn!

Realising the differences

As I sat back & observed my daughter’s behaviour while watching t.v. on the weekend I saw the same pattern repeating it’s self – rude, aggressive, downright naughty! I feel as if I’m at the end of my tether with her behaviour & I can safely say, though I’m not trying to pass the buck as a parent, t.v. is definitely a factor! So I think I will take this experiment a step further & not allow t.v. unless it’s family t.v. (all of us watching a show/movie together) as she becomes recluse, distant & just does not want to interact with anyone when tv is on.


I can safely say this experiment has really opened my eyes, I’ve always known how indoctrinating t.v. can be, but never did anything about it & continued to let my child be exposed to it, big fail on my part! So now I’m looking at a brighter future with less t.v. & more fun & games!

Have you conducted a similar experiment? Would you brave the challenge? Let me know in the comments below and don’t forget to share!!

Follow:
Share:

22 Comments

  1. 19/05/2018 / 11:21 pm

    Nice post.It is difficult to cut down screen timings of children.Mothers will have to limit themsekves first.

  2. 19/05/2018 / 2:44 am

    This couldn’t have come at a better time. My kids are 4&2 and fight al the time and it’s always WW3 in our house UNless Tv is on. I’m looosing my mind with their behavior and maybe I need to detox. I have started spending more time out of the house. Also for Ramadan I’m playing more Islamic cartoons and ignoring the Dora and Daniel and other requests. What is too much for them to watch? My kids don’t want more an hour a day sometimes 2 if I need to cook. Mind you I have a 4,2 yr and 7 month old so I need the TV to help distract them sometimes. How do you suggest I start?

    • thrifdee77
      Author
      19/05/2018 / 3:46 am

      One hour is really ok, as long as it’s something beneficial & they’re not fighting! maybe you could set them up a colouring station while cooking? the 2yr old can try chubby crayons or there’s even Crayola mats that use water pens and they come out in colour on the mat, completely mess free & safe!

  3. 18/05/2018 / 9:58 pm

    This is amazing! Well done! I’ve shared this article with my brother because my nephew goes into zombie mode as well when he watches TV and becomes completely unresponsive. Thanks for sharing!

  4. 18/05/2018 / 9:56 pm

    This is amazing! We’ll done! I’ve shared this article with my brother because my nephew goes into zombie mode when he watches TV and becomes completely unresponsive. Thanks for sharing!

    • thrifdee77
      Author
      18/05/2018 / 9:58 pm

      Thank you for reading & sharing, much appreciated!

  5. 18/05/2018 / 4:30 am

    Kudos for your achievement ! You wrote everything without sugar coating it. The struggle with kids, is real. Its hard to keep them away from tv, I gave up many a times with my nephews. They are super messy kiddos and could do anything for tv. But now my house is at peace when my sissies are at their in laws. Both my sisyers are struggling as well to keep them away from watching tv. But at the end of the day, their tired selbes just give up. Will share this with them! Thank you.

    • thrifdee77
      Author
      18/05/2018 / 4:40 am

      Yes its hard & tv can be an easy distraction, but we must strive to keep them away if we want them to grow up on the right path & not be indoctrinated. Thank you for reading❤

  6. 17/05/2018 / 4:12 pm

    I grew up with out any screen time when I was small. The TV was switched off during Ramadan for everyone and that included me lol no cartoons. I understand some parents just allowing it because it keeps their children entertained during iftaar or tarawee when they need some peace or the fast is getting to them and they need to calm the children down. I think there are many ways to keep your child entertained during ramadan and InshaAllah Allah make it easy for all parents because it does get hard especially during long fasts. Best is to plan as many activities in advance, have gifts as a reward system on hand lol and just be inclusive. Thank you for sharing 🙂

  7. Farhana Sharmeen
    15/05/2018 / 7:32 pm

    “I honestly don’t know where it is!”who said this, you or your daughter?

    • thrifdee77
      Author
      15/05/2018 / 7:37 pm

      Me – (honestly don’t know where it is!” I entertained her idea to look for it)

  8. 14/05/2018 / 5:22 pm

    Indeed there are immense benefits of going cable free! We’ve been cable free for 4 years now and love the results! Our family doesn’t even miss t.v!

  9. 14/05/2018 / 3:59 pm

    I am glad you tried this experiment. It is interesting to see the results. The outcome is amazing!
    Spending quality time with kids is really important for their mental state.

  10. 13/05/2018 / 12:21 pm

    I really enjoyed the read, and your journey with this experiement thanks for sharing. My kids are all grown, but if I had the chance to do it again I would definently give it a try.

  11. 10/05/2018 / 10:58 am

    Amazing mashallah! May Allah continue to put Barakah in your life in this way.

    I think the reason I watch TV so much is to fill up the hours. I know 100% when we have children In Shaa Allah TV time will be limited for them and me.

    Did you also eliminate screen time in this experiment?

    • thrifdee77
      Author
      10/05/2018 / 11:03 am

      Ameen, thank you! I’m guilty, I still watch tv when she sleeps lol, but I do limit my phone usage when she’s around…. It’s only fair as I never allow her on any tablet or phone, so I need to model that behavior.

  12. livebythesunshine
    08/05/2018 / 7:33 pm

    I love this! I wish I could cut down my screen time! Sometimes I realize Matt and I are watching TV with our laptops in our laps and our phones in our hands! That’s screen time to the third degree! And I think with kids, that is even more important! I also love how honest you are.. “fly off the handle mom” will likely describe my mom approach!

    • thrifdee77
      Author
      10/05/2018 / 12:16 pm

      That’s triple screening right there!! 😂

  13. 08/05/2018 / 7:29 pm

    Awesome post, Dee! I love that you gave us an honest, real view into the struggles and wins you accomplished with your kids! I try not to watch tv much, because I notice how lazy I start to become. The laundry piles a little higher, we run out of towels, and there are dishes in the sink. TV is such a distraction. Good move, mom!

  14. 08/05/2018 / 7:27 pm

    This was a super interesting read Dee! I know I’m definitely guilty of just handing my niece my phone to watch YouTube instead of actually just spending time with her. What an amazing change in your daughter though!

    • thrifdee77
      Author
      10/05/2018 / 12:18 pm

      Oh, I know that “YouTube is my friend” phase lol…. Yes I am pleased with the outcome!

Leave a Reply